Understanding the Contradiction: Why typeof Array with Objects Returns "Object"

Developers may encounter a surprising phenomenon: when invoking typeof on an array containing objects, it inexplicably returns "object" instead of "array." This article delves into this seemingly contradictory behavior.

By examining an example, let's illustrate the issue:

$.ajax({
    url: 'http://api.twitter.com/1/statuses/user_timeline.json',
    data: { screen_name: 'mick__romney'},
    dataType: 'jsonp',
    success: function(data) {
        console.dir(data); //Array[20]
        alert(typeof data); //Object
    }
});

While console.dir(data) correctly identifies the variable as an array, typeof data incongruously returns "Object."

The explanation lies in JavaScript's peculiar specification, where the typeof operator returns the type of the object's internal [[Class]] property. In the case of arrays, their [[Class]] property is set to "Array," but when surrounded by objects, the [[Class]] property changes to "Object."

To ensure accurate type checking, developers can employ various approaches:

• data instanceof Array: Checks if the variable is an instance of the Array type.
• Array.isArray(data): A method specifically designed to determine if an object is an array.
• Object.prototype.toString.call(data) == '[object Array]': A reliable and widely accepted method for array detection.
• $.isArray(data): A jQuery-specific function designed to check for arrays.

By understanding this peculiarity and utilizing these techniques, developers can effectively handle arrays of objects in their JavaScript code.